Growing Unshackled's Newsletter 4X—Organically

The primary goal was to increase subscribers and boost engagement. We also wanted to maintain a high open rate—ideally between 70-80%. Beyond just numbers, we aimed to use the newsletter to build a stronger connection with the community, since it was the main funnel for selling memberships.

Category
Growth
Platforms
Email & ConvertKit
Deliverables
Subscribers & Engagement
Website
View website

Project Overview

Background & Challenges:

Unshackled started with a subscriber base of around 3,000. The primary challenge was a lack of consistent growth and quality articles. While the newsletter had a dedicated fan base, maintaining and expanding that following was difficult without a clear content strategy.

Objectives:

Unshackled set out to:

  • Increase the number of subscribers.
  • Boost engagement levels with the newsletter.
  • Maintain open rates between 70-80%.

Another important goal was to use the newsletter to engage the community effectively, as it served as a funnel to convert readers into community members.

Approach:

The strategy for growth was organic, with a strong focus on integrating the newsletter as the key CTA across all social channels. We aimed to build a community that valued high-quality, relevant content. Key organic strategies included:

  • Consistent calls to action on social media platforms, encouraging audiences to subscribe.
  • Posting resources and value-driven content that resonated with the specific interests of Unshackled's audience.
  • Utilizing a referral system to encourage readers to share the newsletter, offering incentives for successful referrals.

To increase content engagement:

  • We consistently shared resources and assets that were helpful to readers.
  • Conducted A/B testing on email subject lines and content formats to determine what resonated best.
  • Took feedback directly from readers, allowing us to tailor content to their preferences.

Implementation:

The content resonated with the target audience by addressing their specific pain points, providing value, and being shareable. We analyzed what made readers click and ensured we continued to deliver such content.

Experimentation was a big part of the process. By A/B testing subject lines, experimenting with different content types, and iterating based on results, we continually refined our approach to maximize effectiveness.

Results:

The campaign resulted in significant growth:

  • The subscriber base grew from 3,000 to 12,000 in just 6 months.
  • Click-through rates jumped from 300 to approximately 1,800.
  • Community engagement and conversions improved, contributing to increased membership sales and revenue.

Lessons Learned:

This experience proved that organic growth is possible when consistent effort is put into understanding the audience's needs and making adjustments based on feedback. A significant takeaway was the importance of accounting for external factors (like holidays and events) that can influence engagement metrics.

Unexpected Challenges:

Challenges included interpreting data and dealing with conflicting metrics. Additionally, external factors sometimes caused fluctuations in open and engagement rates, which required careful consideration when planning content.

Impact

The increased attention on the newsletter had a broader impact on Unshackled's business, including:

  • Greater website traffic.
  • Increased leads.
  • Improved conversions, directly translating into higher revenue for the company.

Testimonial:

"

Browse my latest work

I talk about marketing, product, tech, and photography—all from my own experiences, navigating both personal and professional life.

More about me